The Guthrie City Council will consider an appeal Tuesday from a property owner seeking to retain the exposed brick façade at 220 E. Harrison Ave. after the Historic Preservation Commission rejected the request in a split vote.
Jennifer Bozarth is asking the council to overturn the commission’s Nov. 2 decision denying a Certificate of Appropriateness for the brick exterior. A motion to allow the brick to remain exposed failed 4-3.
The appeal follows several months of discussions over the building’s appearance after its Vitrolite tile façade was removed. The council’s consideration of the appeal is scheduled for Tuesday night.
According to the staff summary provided for the appeal, the application first came before the commission in June with a proposal for painted brick. Commissioners continued the matter to allow Bozarth to revise the design to reflect an Art Deco style with colors similar to surrounding buildings.
In July, the commission approved an Art Deco design with conditions requiring appropriate materials for the stucco and architectural features. Additional changes were presented in October after damage was discovered during removal of an awning. Commissioners approved maintaining the existing door and windows but took no action on the proposed brick façade.
At the Nov. 2 meeting, Bozarth presented information she said addressed earlier concerns about whether the brick could withstand exterior exposure.
Bozarth told commissioners she obtained a letter from Acme Brick identifying the material as meeting severe-weather classification standards. She also said mason Brad Hill inspected the building and found the brick suitable for exterior use.
“Because the original brick is in good condition and suitable for exterior use, I believe preserving and properly cleaning it is preferable to covering it with a new finish,” Bozarth said.
Despite the letter, long-standing HPC member Valerie Duncan says her main concern is the brick facade.
“I’m certainly not an expert in brick, and so I’m not going to argue with the experts, but I’ve looked at the brick. I’ve touched it, and it is not in good shape,” Duncan explained to Bozarth in the meeting.” However, like I said, I don’t want to argue with the experts on this, but my main concern is that it was never a brick façade. The brick was not exposed when the building was built. It was an Art Deco one, and it was covered with the Vitrolite tile. So I understand you removed that and that it would be a huge investment to replace that, and that’s why we offered the option of stucco last time. If you restore it to have no Art Deco features, unlike when it was built, then I think we’ve lost something important in Guthrie, and that’s just my opinion.”
Commission discussion focused on both the brick’s condition and the importance of preserving the building’s Art Deco appearance. Members opposing the request argued that leaving the brick exposed would remove a significant architectural feature associated with the storefront’s former tile exterior.
Councilwoman Menecca Gibbs, who serves as the exoffico for HPC, agreed with Duncan.
“We’re not just trying to keep everything brick, but how it was originally intended. And that Art Deco time period is a time period that we have to preserve as well. Even though it is modern to some, it’s still a hundred years old that we think of now. And it is a time period that we are supposed to preserve, even if it’s not just brick. It is a design that happened, and it did happen as Guthrie was in its evolution period.”
During public comments, Carol Hirzel asked whether Bozarth should be allowed to restore the exposed brick façade.
“So, shouldn’t she be able to go back to the original brick and fit with everything else in the district?” Hirzel asked.
Gibbs responded that the building had been the last with a full Vitrolite storefront.
“Thank goodness,” Hirzel replied.
“Well, you say that, but there aren’t any more,” Gibbs responded, adding that Oklahoma City had removed most of its Vitrolite façades.
Other commissioners supported allowing the brick, citing the information Bozarth presented and observations of the building.
The discussion also revealed differing views about the building’s construction date and when the tile façade was installed. Those questions were not resolved during the meeting.
“If I could answer something, a point that you brought up, that you said it’s her building and if she wants it brick, why can’t it be brick,” Duncan said. “I’m not on this council—or commission—to tell people what they can do with their building. I don’t want to do that. However, that’s why we have zoning laws. That’s why we have restrictions. That’s why we have this ordinance right here.”
Commissioner Lisa Kennedy spoke to Hirzel and said, “You could just get a building that’s not in the historic district, and then you don’t have to abide by the rules of HPC. Our goal is to make every building contributing so we get grant funds for the city. If it’s non-contributing, we don’t get that money.”
Bozarth questioned whether the commission’s concerns had shifted from the durability of the brick to the building’s architectural style.
“What I’m addressing tonight is I was told it was not exterior brick, and that’s why they (HPC) denied at the last meeting. So now you’re saying something different, that it’s now because it wasn’t Art Deco. So the last meeting, and what’s in your minutes of the last meeting, is that you denied it because it was not exterior-grade brick.”
Commission member Nathan Turner moved to allow the exposed brick façade, citing the professional assessments Bozarth presented.
“We have somebody that knows brick more than any of us do is telling us that it’s quality brick. It’s everything that she needs to do,” Turner said.
Darrell Covington seconded the motion.
The motion, however, failed 4-3. Duncan, Matthew Knight, Stephen Harrison and Kennedy voted against it, while Carol McPeek, Turner and Covington voted in favor.
Following the vote, she requested the specific preservation guidelines supporting the denial.
The city council is expected to hear the appeal at 6:30 p.m. inside City Hall’s council chambers.



Be the first to comment on "City Council to hear appeal over brick façade at downtown Guthrie building"