County determining options for expired lease on road grader

Commissioners Mike Pearson (L) and Marven Goodman listen to Warren CAT officials on the expired lease purchase on a road grader.

Legal counsel for the Board of County Commissioners is now considering what options are available for an expired lease purchase agreement for a road grader in District 2.


In the August 31 BOCC meeting, District 2 Commissioner-elect Kody Ellis spoke under public comments requesting information from current District 2 Commissioner Mike Pearson.

“What is the status of the 2015 (road) grader that we leased from Warren CAT? The balloon payment,” Ellis asked after being elected just six days prior to the meeting in an election win over Pearson.

Pearson said he was uncertain on the status and asked that Ellis get with him later to discuss the matter.

During the commissioner comments portion of the meeting, District 1 Commissioner Marven Goodman expanded on the lease purchase conversation. Goodman requested that all the lease purchase agreements for county equipment — within District 2 — be made available for the Sept. 8 meeting.

The BOCC approves and signs off on all county equipment, which includes lease purchases.

At Tuesday’s meeting, Goodman began the conversation by supplying a three-page document on state statures in regards to an election year, including a highlighted portion that reads:

However, in the case of lease-purchase contracts, rental, lease or other payments extending beyond the term of office of the commissioner it shall be the mandatory duty of the commissioner to execute and to make such payments current as of the date of expiration of the term of office of the commissioner. The commissioner shall be liable both personally and on the official bond of the commissioner for any violation of the mandatory duties herein imposed.

The lease on the questioned grader is reported to have expired, in which, Pearson agreed with.

“It (grader) was over hours and it caught us unaware as well as CAT,” Pearson said. “In order to figure out what to do about that, we have inquired with the state auditor, who has now referred that to the Assistant District Attorney Lowell Barto. He is looking into that.”

“You’re legally on the hook for it. You probably should,” Goodman told Pearson.

Pearson added, “We can’t surplus it because I did not win re-election and we can not purchase it. We are currently making payments. Here’s all the information that you requested, sir,” Pearson said has he handed over a deep stack of papers.

The lease purchase agreement included a 5,000 hour max or five years. The current hours on the grader is reportedly recorded at 7,240 hours.

At the end of the contract, the County had the option of turning the grader back to CAT, or pay the balloon payment of $180,000. However, since the hours have been spent with no formal action taken, the contract is now null and voided.

On June 15, the BOCC voted (3-0) unanimously, in part, to renew the fiscal year 2020-21 lease agreement for the grader with CAT Financial.

CAT officials, who were in attendance on Tuesday, said there are a few options available, including trade the grader for a new machine with a trade assessment on the value of the current state of the grader, or pay the difference between the assessed value and what is owed.

Goodman requested the conversation be continued at the next BOCC meeting scheduled for Sept. 15 at 9 a.m.


Be the first to comment on "County determining options for expired lease on road grader"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.